top of page

Handle a Boss Who Plays Favorites: Calm Words and Next Steps

Updated: 2 days ago

Woman in her late 20s holding a notebook and standing thoughtfully in a bright glass-walled office as she learns to handle a boss who plays favorites, in the blog by Asi Efros

"Every time a good project comes up, it goes to the same two people, and they are not even the ones with the most experience. I keep working hard, and I am starting to wonder whether it matters."


If your boss seems to play favorites, please know that the discouragement you feel is understandable, and that wanting fair treatment is a reasonable wish. Watching opportunities go to others can leave you feeling hurt, overlooked, and unsure of what to do next. This article shares what research says about favoritism at work, and it offers calm words and gentle next steps. It is general information and not legal or career advice, and an HR professional or an employment attorney can speak to your own situation.


What Research Says as You Handle a Boss Who Plays Favorites


Researchers at Stevens Institute of Technology and other universities studied favoritism in teams, and they described their findings in a summary of the study published in the journal Personnel Psychology in 2023. They surveyed more than 200 teams, including over 1,100 employees, at several companies in China across different industries, and they surveyed both employees and supervisors. The results were mixed. In teams that already had clear structure, such as defined authority or differing skill levels, performance dropped when leaders played favorites. In less structured teams, favoritism often improved coordination and performance across the whole team, and it was more likely to destabilize newer teams.


These findings come from one setting and one country, so they describe a pattern and do not predict what happens in your office. They do offer a hopeful lesson: favoritism is not always a reflection of your work, and structure and clarity tend to protect fairness. When roles, criteria, and expectations are clear, there is less room for preference to decide who receives opportunities.


Gallup, the research and analytics company, reports in its article on what employees want from managers that employees want fair, consistent accountability that applies the same standards to everyone. The article also notes that managers account for at least 70 percent of the variance in employee engagement scores, which shows how much a leader's choices shape the daily experience of work. Wanting fairness is a normal, healthy expectation.


Seeing the Situation Clearly as You Handle a Boss Who Plays Favorites


Before you decide what to do, it helps to look at the situation with a calm and open mind. Here are some gentle questions to explore:


  1. What exactly is happening? Note specific examples, such as projects assigned, meetings invited, or feedback given, instead of general impressions.

  2. Is there a pattern? One decision may have a reason you cannot see, while a repeated pattern deserves attention.

  3. What might explain it? Sometimes a leader leans on people who have recent related experience, or people who ask directly for work.

  4. How does it affect you? Consider your workload, your growth, your pay, and your confidence.

  5. What outcome would feel fair? Perhaps you would like a stretch assignment, a clearer path to promotion, or simply more visibility.


It also helps to remember that a favorite is not necessarily doing anything wrong. Your colleagues may not be aware of the dynamic, and resentment toward them rarely helps you. Keeping your relationships warm protects your reputation and your peace of mind. It can also help to notice what you control, such as the quality of your work, the clarity of your goals, and the way you ask for opportunities. Putting your energy there tends to feel steadier than trying to change how someone else makes decisions, and it keeps your confidence anchored in your own progress.


Calm Words for a Private Conversation as You Handle a Boss Who Plays Favorites


If you decide to speak with your boss, a private, specific, forward-looking conversation tends to work best. Many people find it helpful to focus on their own goals and avoid naming other people, because that keeps the conversation collaborative. Here is a gentle structure:


  • Choose a quiet moment. Ask for a short one-on-one meeting, and begin with appreciation, such as "I enjoy working on this team."

  • Share your goal. "I would like to grow into more visible projects, and I want to understand how assignments are decided."

  • Ask about the process. "What would help me be considered for the next client project?"

  • Describe your strengths. "I led the vendor transition last quarter, and I would be glad to apply that experience again."

  • Request a next step. "Could we agree that I take the lead on one project this quarter?"

  • Listen. Your boss may share context you did not know, and listening keeps the tone friendly.

  • Confirm in writing. A short email afterward, such as "Thank you for talking with me, and I look forward to leading the next phase," keeps a record.


Between conversations, a few steady habits can strengthen your position. Share your accomplishments in a brief weekly update, so that your results are visible. Volunteer for work that matters to your team's goals. Build relationships with leaders in other departments, who may see your contributions from a fresh angle. Ask a mentor to speak with you about your career path, and invite their perspective on how to be considered for new roles.


Taking Next Steps as You Handle a Boss Who Plays Favorites


If the pattern continues after a thoughtful conversation, you have options. Here are some ideas:


  • Involve a mentor or sponsor. A senior colleague who values your work can advocate for you when decisions are made.

  • Speak with HR. An HR professional can explain your company's process, and they may help clarify how opportunities are assigned.

  • Document your examples. Keep dated notes about specific decisions and their effect on your work.

  • Explore other teams. An internal move can open a new path with a leader who values your strengths.

  • Know your protections. If you believe you are being treated unfairly because of a protected characteristic, such as sex, race, age, or disability, an employment attorney or the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission can explain your options.


Favoritism can wear on your confidence, so please look after yourself too. Name the feeling to a trusted friend, protect your sleep and your breaks, and remember what you do well. Review your accomplishments, your reviews, and the kind notes you have saved. Keep your options open by updating your resume and talking with people outside your team. Many employers also offer an Employee Assistance Program with free, confidential counseling.


If frustration or sadness stays heavy for weeks, or if it affects your sleep and your enjoyment of life, please talk with your primary care provider or a mental health professional.


In my experience as a life coach, people who gather specific examples, ask about the process, and request one concrete opportunity often find that their boss responds more openly than they expected.


Your work has value, and you deserve a workplace where opportunities are shared fairly.


Ready to Ask for What You Deserve?


If you want a steady place to plan your words and build your confidence, you do not have to do it alone. Book a Free 30-Minute Chat with Asi Efros to talk through a plan that fits you.



I hope this blog post "Handle a Boss Who Plays Favorites: Calm Words and Next Steps" was helpful. You can find more insights like this on the blog 👉 Explore more insights on the blog


CREATE YOUR DREAM LIFE, CAREER & BUSINESS — one aligned step at a time.


Comments


bottom of page